Dog Bite Lawsuits in New York: The Law and Your Claim

New York has no single dog bite statute. A bite claim can rest on strict liability if the owner knew the dog was dangerous, on ordinary negligence since Flanders v. Goodfellow (2025), or both. Most claims must be filed within three years under CPLR §214(5).

Last updated November 2026
Laurence P. Banville, New York personal injury attorney
Laurence P. Banville Managing Partner · NY & D.C. Bars
The bottom line: New York has no single dog bite statute. A bite claim usually rests on two court-made rules: strict liability when the owner knew or should have known the dog was dangerous, and, since 2025, ordinary negligence when the owner failed to use reasonable care. A separate statute makes the owner of a dog already found dangerous strictly liable for medical costs. Most bite claims must be filed within three years.

What is the New York dog bite statute?

There isn’t one statute that covers every bite. Some states have passed laws that make owners liable for any bite. New York has not. Here, the rules come mostly from Court of Appeals decisions, with one statute that adds a narrower remedy. In practice, an injured person can rely on three routes, alone or together.

Route 1: Strict liability for a dog with known vicious propensities

An owner who knew or should have known that the dog had vicious propensities is strictly liable for the harm those propensities cause. That is the rule of Collier v. Zambito, 1 N.Y.3d 444 (2004). “Vicious propensity” is broader than it sounds. It covers any tendency to act in a way that could endanger people, not only a history of biting.

The Court in Collier listed the kinds of evidence that can show the owner was on notice:

  • Prior bites or attacks the owner knew about.
  • Growling, snapping or baring teeth, even if the dog never bit anyone.
  • How the dog was restrained, and why. Chaining or confining a dog because the owner feared it could support an inference of knowledge.
  • Keeping the dog as a guard dog.

The Court also noted what does not count: barking and running around are what dogs do. Once the owner’s knowledge is shown, the owner does not escape liability by saying they were careful. This is why prompt evidence matters. Neighbors forget, complaint records get lost, and the dog’s past can be hard to reconstruct later. Names of witnesses, photos of warning signs or chains, and prior complaints to a landlord or the city are worth gathering early.

Route 2: Negligence, available since 2025

For almost twenty years, Bard v. Jahnke, 6 N.Y.3d 592 (2006) barred negligence claims against the owner of a domestic animal. That changed in Flanders v. Goodfellow, 44 N.Y.3d 57 (2025). The Court of Appeals overruled Bard to the extent it barred negligence liability for harm caused by domestic animals. A person bitten by a dog now has a choice: seek strict liability if the owner knew of the dog’s vicious propensities, prove that the owner failed to use reasonable care, or plead both.

Negligence matters most when the dog had no known history. Examples of careless conduct include letting a dog roam loose, leaving a broken gate or fence unrepaired, or handling the dog carelessly around strangers or children. Many cities and towns have local leash rules, and breaking one can be evidence of carelessness.

Route 3: The dangerous dog law and medical costs

Under Agriculture and Markets Law §123(10), the owner or lawful custodian of a dangerous dog is strictly liable for medical costs resulting from injury the dog causes to a person. This only applies where the dog meets the statute’s definition of a dangerous dog, and it covers medical costs only, not pain and suffering or lost earnings. Subdivision 12 says the section does not limit any common-law or statutory claim, so the routes above remain open. Older cases cite this law as former §121. The court process for declaring a dog dangerous is explained in our guide to New York’s dangerous dog proceeding.

Who can be sued?

  • The owner, and anyone who keeps or harbors the dog.
  • A landlord, in limited cases. Under Strunk v. Zoltanski, 62 N.Y.2d 572 (1984) and later decisions, a landlord can be liable for a tenant’s dog if the landlord knew of the dog and its vicious propensities and had the control or ability to remove or confine it.
  • A veterinary clinic. In Hewitt v. Palmer Veterinary Clinic, 35 N.Y.3d 541 (2020), the Court held that a clinic whose patient attacked someone in its waiting room is judged by ordinary negligence, without proof that it knew of the dog’s vicious propensities.

What defenses do owners raise?

The most common defense is that the owner had no notice of any dangerous tendency. Owners may also argue that the injured person provoked the dog, for example by hitting or tormenting it, or that the person was committing a crime on the owner’s property. The dangerous dog statute lists these situations in subdivisions 4 and 11.

Who pays, and what is a claim worth?

In most cases the owner’s homeowner’s or renter’s liability insurance pays. The injured person does not usually report the bite to their own insurer. The claim is made against the owner, whose policy typically requires the owner to notify the insurance company promptly.

No average settlement fits every case, and this page does not quote figures. Value depends on the injuries and the evidence. Damages can include medical bills and future treatment, scarring and disfigurement, lost earnings, and pain and suffering. When a child is bitten on the face, the scars can call for revision surgery years later and affect the child well into adulthood. These lasting effects weigh heavily in valuing a claim.

How long do you have to sue?

Most bite claims must be filed within three years under CPLR §214(5). For a child, CPLR §208 generally extends the deadline. If a city, county, public housing authority or other public entity is involved, a notice of claim is generally due within 90 days under General Municipal Law §50-e. The full rules are in our page on the dog bite statute of limitations in New York. Reporting is separate: see when to report a dog bite and whether a doctor must report a dog bite.

Do I need a lawyer for a dog bite?

Not always. A minor nip that heals in a few days with no scar may not need a lawyer, and the owner’s insurer may simply pay the urgent care bill. A lawyer is worth calling when there are stitches, a facial wound, a child victim, nerve damage, an infection, missed work, or an insurer disputing that the owner knew about the dog. Sooner is better: within days or weeks of the bite, while witnesses remember and the dog’s history can still be documented.

Consultations for injury claims are typically free, and injury lawyers usually work on a contingency fee, meaning nothing up front and a fee only if there is a recovery. For how injury cases move from claim to lawsuit, see how a New York personal injury lawsuit works and our overview of New York personal injury case types. Banville Law reviews these claims and refers or co-counsels them with trial counsel where a case calls for it.

Frequently asked questions

Is New York a strict liability state for dog bites?

Only partly. Unlike states that make owners liable for any bite, New York imposes strict liability when the owner knew or should have known of the dog’s vicious propensities, under Collier v. Zambito (2004). Agriculture and Markets Law §123(10) adds strict liability for medical costs when the dog is a dangerous dog under that statute. Without that knowledge, the claim usually proceeds in negligence.

Can I sue a dog owner for negligence in New York?

Yes. Since Flanders v. Goodfellow (2025), the Court of Appeals has allowed negligence claims against owners of domestic animals, overruling the earlier bar from Bard v. Jahnke. You must show the owner failed to use reasonable care, for example by letting the dog roam loose or ignoring a broken fence. You can also plead strict liability in the same case.

Can I sue my landlord for a tenant’s dog biting me?

Sometimes. Under Strunk v. Zoltanski (1984) and later cases, a landlord can be liable if the landlord knew the tenant’s dog was there, knew of its vicious propensities, and had the control or ability to remove or confine it. A landlord who knew nothing about the dog’s behavior is generally not liable.

Does homeowner’s insurance pay for a dog bite?

Usually the dog owner’s homeowner’s or renter’s liability policy is the source of payment. Coverage depends on the policy, and some policies limit or exclude certain dogs. The injured person makes the claim against the owner, and the owner’s policy typically requires the owner to notify the insurer promptly after the bite.

Do I need a lawyer for a dog bite in New York?

Not for every bite. A small nip that heals without a scar may be resolved directly with the owner’s insurer. A lawyer is worth consulting for stitches, facial injuries, injured children, infections, lost work, or a dispute over whether the owner knew of the danger. Injury lawyers typically offer a free consultation and charge nothing up front.

What if the dog never bit anyone before?

You may still have a claim. Courts reject a one free bite rule: growling, snapping, baring teeth, or confinement out of fear can show the owner was on notice. And since Flanders v. Goodfellow (2025), you can sue in negligence without proving any prior dangerous behavior, if the owner failed to use reasonable care.

Laurence P. Banville

Reviewed by Laurence P. Banville, Esq.

Managing Partner, Banville Law · New York & D.C. Bars

Laurence Banville is a New York personal injury attorney and the Managing Partner of Banville Law. Born in County Wexford, Ireland, he earned his law degree summa cum laude from University College Dublin and once defended insurance companies in product-liability litigation — experience he now uses for injured New Yorkers. He has been named to the Irish Legal 100 and the Irish Echo’s Top 40 Under 40, and is an AVVO Rated attorney.

NY Bar D.C. Bar Irish Legal 100 AVVO Rated AAJ Member

Read Laurence’s full bio →

Free case review

Tell us what happened. We’ll tell you where you stand.

A free, no-pressure review with a New York attorney — in plain English. We’ll explain your options and the deadlines that matter.

  • Free & confidential — no obligation
  • A real answer about your NY claim, not a sales pitch
  • No fee unless we win your case

Prefer to talk now? (917) 551-6690

Laurence P. Banville, Esq., New York personal injury attorney
Laurence P. Banville, Esq. Managing Partner — he personally reviews every case review request.
Do You Qualify?
  • Details
  • Incident
  • Aftermath

Free Case Evaluation

Call now Free case review