What happens after a dog bite is reported in New York?
Two separate tracks can start: a health track, where the local health department looks at rabies risk, and a dangerous dog track, which asks whether the dog poses a continuing danger. To report a bite, see when and how to report a dog bite in New York. Doctors and hospitals have their own reporting duty, covered in whether a doctor has to report a dog bite.
Will the dog be quarantined after a bite?
Under the State Sanitary Code, 10 NYCRR §2.14, the local health authority may have a dog, cat or ferret confined for 10 days after a person is exposed, and the cost of that confinement is the owner’s expense. In New York City, the owner of a dog that has bitten a person must closely observe it for 10 days under NYC Health Code §11.27(e).
What is a dangerous dog under New York law?
The definition is in Agriculture and Markets Law §108(24). A dangerous dog is one that:
- without justification attacks a person, companion animal, farm animal or domestic animal and causes physical injury or death;
- behaves in a way a reasonable person would believe poses a serious and unjustified imminent threat of serious physical injury or death; or
- without justification attacks a service dog, guide dog or hearing dog and causes physical injury or death.
Police work dogs on duty are excluded. A dog does not have to bite anyone to qualify.
How a dangerous dog proceeding works
Under Agriculture and Markets Law §123(1), any person who witnesses an attack or threatened attack may complain to a dog control officer or police officer. If there is reason to believe the dog is dangerous, the officer must start the proceeding.
The complaint is made under oath to a municipal judge or justice. If the judge finds probable cause, the judge can order the dog seized and held pending a decision. A hearing must be held within five days, on at least two days’ written notice to the owner. The person bringing the case must prove the dog is dangerous by clear and convincing evidence.
If the dog is found dangerous, the judge must order it spayed or neutered and microchipped, plus one or more other measures, such as:
- behaviorist evaluation and recommended training, at the owner’s cost;
- secure, humane confinement for a period and in a manner the court sets;
- restraint on a leash by an adult at least 21 years old in public places;
- muzzling in public places;
- a liability insurance policy in an amount set by the court, “but in no event in excess of one hundred thousand dollars” under Agriculture and Markets Law §123(2).
How many times can a dog bite before it is put down?
New York law has no bite count. Under Agriculture and Markets Law §123(3), a judge who finds a dog dangerous may order humane euthanasia or permanent confinement only if one of these is proven at the hearing:
- the dog, without justification, attacked a person causing serious physical injury or death;
- the dog has a known vicious propensity shown by a previous unjustified attack on a person that caused serious physical injury or death; or
- the dog, without justification, seriously injured or killed a companion, farm or domestic animal and, within the past two years, had a dangerous dog finding for injuring or killing a companion or farm animal.
A single attack causing serious physical injury can be enough; several minor nips may not be. If the owner appeals within 30 days of the final order, a euthanasia order is automatically stayed while the appeal is pending under Agriculture and Markets Law §123(5).
Defenses written into the statute
Agriculture and Markets Law §123(4) bars a dangerous dog finding where the dog’s conduct was justified: the person was committing a crime or offense against the owner or the owner’s property, had tormented, abused or threatened the dog or its offspring, or the dog was responding to pain or protecting itself, its owner or its household. Agriculture and Markets Law §123(11) shields the owner from the penalties and liability in subdivisions 6 through 10 where the dog injured someone committing certain serious crimes on the owner’s property.
Penalties on the owner and the cost of a dog bite citation
The owner can face penalties under the same section:
- negligently permitting a dog to bite a person causing physical injury: a civil penalty “not to exceed four hundred dollars” under Agriculture and Markets Law §123(6);
- negligently permitting a bite causing serious physical injury: a civil penalty “not to exceed one thousand five hundred dollars” under Agriculture and Markets Law §123(7), which may be reduced by restitution paid to the injured person;
- negligently permitting a dog previously found dangerous to bite and seriously injure a person: a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of “not more than three thousand dollars” or up to ninety days in jail under Agriculture and Markets Law §123(8);
- a dog previously found dangerous that, without justification, kills a person: a class A misdemeanor under Agriculture and Markets Law §123(9).
Medical costs and the injured person’s claim
Under Agriculture and Markets Law §123(10), the owner of a dangerous dog is strictly liable for medical costs the dog causes, subject to the statutory defenses. A full injury claim can rest on the owner’s knowledge of the dog’s vicious propensities under Collier v. Zambito (2004), and since Flanders v. Goodfellow (2025) the Court of Appeals also allows ordinary negligence claims, overruling Bard v. Jahnke (2006) to the extent it barred them. See the guide to suing for a dog bite in New York and the dog bite statute of limitations.
New York City: the Health Department process
Under NYC Health Code §161.01, a Health Department record of a bite report made under NYC Health Code §11.03, or a police report of a dog bite, is prima facie evidence that a dog is dangerous for purposes of the city’s rules. Under NYC Health Code §161.07, if the owner disputes the Department’s preliminary finding, the case goes to a hearing at the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH). The Commissioner’s orders can range from muzzling to removal from the city or surrender for euthanasia.
Is a dog bite report public record, and how long does it stay on record?
Bite reports and dangerous dog files are kept by the health department, police or dog control, and the court. Requests to agencies fall under the Freedom of Information Law, Public Officers Law Article 6, which does not cover court files. In New York City, NYC Health Code §161.07(m) allows dangerous dog records to be released under the Public Officers Law, but identifying details about injured people and complainants must be redacted when someone else asks. No provision in Agriculture and Markets Law §123 makes a dangerous dog finding expire. A prior finding triggers the higher penalties in subdivisions 8 and 9.
Banville Law reviews dog bite injury claims and refers or co-counsels them with trial counsel where a case calls for it. See also our overview of New York personal injury cases.
Frequently asked questions
What happens after a dog bite is reported in New York?
The local health department checks rabies risk, which usually means the dog is watched for 10 days. Separately, if anyone believes the dog is dangerous, a dog control officer or police officer can bring the case before a local judge under Agriculture and Markets Law §123. The judge decides whether the dog is dangerous and what restrictions apply. Neither step is the injured person’s claim for damages.
How many times can a dog bite before it is put down in New York?
There is no set number. A judge may order euthanasia or permanent confinement only after finding the dog dangerous and finding a listed aggravating circumstance, such as an unjustified attack that caused a person serious physical injury or death, or a prior unjustified attack of that kind. One serious attack can be enough. Many minor bites may lead only to restrictions such as leashing or muzzling.
What is a dangerous dog under New York law?
Agriculture and Markets Law §108(24) defines it as a dog that, without justification, attacks a person or certain animals and causes physical injury or death, attacks a service, guide or hearing dog, or acts in a way a reasonable person would see as a serious and unjustified imminent threat of serious injury or death. A dog can qualify without ever biting.
Will the dog be quarantined after a bite?
Usually it is observed for 10 days. Under 10 NYCRR §2.14 the local health authority may order the dog confined for 10 days, at the owner’s expense. In New York City, the owner must closely watch a dog that bit someone for 10 days under Health Code §11.27. The goal is to rule out rabies for the person who was bitten.
Is a dog bite report public record?
Not automatically. Reports held by a health department, police or dog control agency can be requested under New York’s Freedom of Information Law, Public Officers Law Article 6, and agencies may withhold or redact some material. In New York City, Health Code §161.07(m) requires identifying details of injured people and complainants to be removed when someone else requests dangerous dog records. Court files are handled separately by the court.
How much is a dog bite citation in New York?
Under Agriculture and Markets Law §123, an owner who negligently lets a dog bite someone faces a civil penalty of up to four hundred dollars for physical injury and up to fifteen hundred dollars for serious physical injury. If the dog was already found dangerous, a serious injury becomes a misdemeanor with a fine of up to three thousand dollars, up to ninety days in jail, or both. Local leash rules can add separate fines.